HP41 Intermittent Key



#5

I recently acquired a 41. One key requires 2 presses sometimes before it works. (Its the '2' key, ironically.)

Has anyone had this type of problem on this calculator and fixed it? I've found the document in the museum about procedures to fix "Bad Keys". Does anyone know if that procedure is appropriate for the 41? How dangerous is this fix attempt?

Thanks.

Jim


#6

I have repaired NUMEROUS HP41 keys using the wire brush method. Take two or three fine but stiff bristles from a wire brush and chuck them into a pin vise or exakto knife holder. Trim their ends even.

Find the offending key on the back of the keyboard. There will be a small hole under it near the center of the key click disk. Place a drop of 91% isopropyl alcohol on the hole, dip the wire brush bristles in alcohol, insert the wire brush bristles and gently "scritch" away at the disk under the hole for a few seconds. Work the bristles all around the hole. Be careful not to break a bristle off in the hole.

This also works quite well on HP25 series machines and possibly others.


#7

That's a neat trick -- I must try it sometime. I think it would work
on just about any HP with the metal-dome keyboards, and of course it doesn't involve
undoing the heat-staking with all the problems of putting it back together again.
Thanks for posting it.


#8

that wire bristle method sounds like something to try if the dome for that key is flatened and the key dosn't "snap" like the others but if it feels like the others i would first try hosing it down with tv tuner cleaner in case the problem is just dirt. i'll remember that wire trick though.

#9

Thanks a million for the ideas. (This internet thing....even though I've been using it for 12+ years.....continues to astound me.....)

I have a few follow-up questions:
* How dangerous is it to take the calculator apart? Is there a high risk of permanently breaking something?
* Is it fairly obvious how to get to the keyboard? For example, once I get the case parts apart do I need to unplug or disconnect components to get to the keyboard?
* In the things I've read 4 screws are described; I believe one under each of the rubber feet. The two rubber feet above the battery pack do *not* have screws under them. The feet below the battery pack do have screws under them. Were there models with only 2 screws holding it together?

Thanks again.

Jim


#10

All the '41 calcs have four screws, one below each foot. It is quite easy to open and close the '41s. Just be real careful not to overtorque the screws when putting it together again. In particular the upper screw bosses in the case back have a tendency to break because the plastic is quite thin and had become a bit brittle with age (actually HP knew they had a problem here soon after the machines were released). The lower screw posts can also crack off if you get the screws past their limits.

Another problem that occurs is the screw posts split vertically. They can be repaired with styrene melting solvent (plastic welder) available at most good hobby shops (Hobbytown carries it). Brush it onto the outside and inside of the cracks, hold the post together for about a minute, then let it set up overnight.

The circuit card in the fullnut sits on a conductive elstomer strip (zebra connector) and uses the case tension to hold it in contact with the keyboard.

The half nut designs (rounded LCD display corners) have a single chip surface mounted on the keyboard. They do not have the problems associated with the zebra connector system. Their main problem is the the wires to the piezo beeper disk WILL break off if you even think about opening the case. They are rather thin and the solder connections at either end seems to become brittle with age. Expect that you will have to resolder at least one of them. Feel VERY lucky if you don't.

#11

The first thing to be aware of is that the HP41 is almost entirely MOS circuitry and it _is_ possible to damage it by electrostatic discharge. This damage may not show up at the time, the machine may work when it's put back together and then fail days or months later.
It is important to take anti-static precautions (use a proper earthing wrist strap, work on an ESD-protected bench, and so on).
That said, I take reasonable precautions, and have never zapped an HP41 or any other HP calculator.
All HP41s have 4 screws holding them together. Sometimes the feet peel off and leave the sticky layer behind, hiding the screw head. Try peeling it up to find the screws.
The are 2 basic types of HP41, the original (or 'fullnut') and the halfnut. The easiest way to tell them apart is by looking at the display -- the halfnuts have a black border around the display with rounded corners. The fullnuts don't
To take apart a fullnut, remove the battery pack and the 4 screws. Lift off the bottom case (it comes right off). Lift off the centre case as well (a U-shaped piece of plastic -- make sure you put this back the same way up). Looking at the back of the keyboard, you'll see the logic board (covered with chips) in the front. Lift this off too -- early
machines have a couple of nuts you have to remove first. Then you can see the keyboard. There's a hole (a PCB 'via') under each key. Start by spraying a tiny bit of propan-2-ol into the one under the '2' key. if that doesn't hel
then try the wire-brush trick mentioned elsewhere in this thread. The logic board _and the keyboard PCB (which is connected to the display module) are the static-senstive parts. Clean also the contacts betwene the logic board and the keyboard and the ones between the I/O flexible PCB (in the lower case, connects to the modules and the battery pack) and the keyboard. Then put it all back together again. Do not overtighten the screws. A good trick here is to put them in their holes and turn them 'backwards' (counterclockwise) until the threads engage. Then tighten them. This avoids stripping the threads.
On the halfnut models, again start by removing the battery and the 4 screws. The beeper is mounted in the bottom case on these machines, so there are 2 thin wires joining it to the circuit board. Carefully lift up the bottom case and turn it over towards the left side of the machine. Then remove the centre case as above.
There is one PCB in the halfnut, no separate logic board. Again you can clean the keycontacts as above. On the halfnut CX, there's a PCB soldered to pins across the top of the main chip. I think you can get to the keys without desoldering this. You can certainly squirt them.
There's only one set of contacts (keyboard to I/O flexible PCB) to clean in the halfnuts. Put it back, using the methods I described for the fullnut.


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Classic display segment intermittent - cause? Mark Henderson 3 1,221 02-27-2010, 07:25 PM
Last Post: Mark Henderson
  HP 42S - intermittent rows nonfunctional Rob Welch 2 1,145 12-01-2009, 03:49 PM
Last Post: geoff quickfall
  HP-34C Intermittent Display Robert Hollyer 6 1,833 06-07-2007, 01:37 AM
Last Post: Robert Hollyer
  Intermittent IR printing problem from HP 50g Steve Pence 5 1,561 03-22-2007, 12:38 PM
Last Post: Dan
  What is HP41 Tall Key? insect 7 2,244 11-02-2006, 11:26 AM
Last Post: David Smith
  HP41 key press delay (for NULL) Vassilis Prevelakis 1 829 08-28-2003, 07:36 AM
Last Post: Valentin Albillo

Forum Jump: