Collector Responsibility?



#7

I recently bought a 32E (but the model isn't important for this thread). It's in beautiful physical condition, until you get to the internal corrosion issue. As a collector should I feel obligated to get the calculator functioning again, or is a lovely paper weight good enough?


#8

In my opinion you don't have any obligation to fix it.
It's your calc, you bought it, you can do with it whatever you want to do.
The HP32E is quite common and easy to get. No big loss to the collector community if it is not restored. Other Spice models are rarer and more valuable. The common HP32E might serve as a transplant organ spender to revive some on the rarer Spices. Such as replacing burnt out LED displays or worn keyboards (I mean on the solderered variety, not the press-fit ones). I even must admit to have slaughtered a not so pretty but fully functional HP32E recently to get just the battery PCB and the flexfoil to fix a HP38C which also had corrosion by leaky batteries. The HP38C now is in perfect condition again, the HP32E is dead. Was it worth the sacrifice ? For me, yes. I also buy worn / ugly HP45 just to cannibalize them for LED display modules and chips to repair the more valuable Classics, the HP55s being particular notorious for burnt out LEDs.
So there is nothing wrong with not restoring your HP32E. If you are new to restoring HPs and want to get a little practice, try to replace the corroded parts with thin wires. But don't blame me if you break the case in the process...

Regards,
Bernhard

#9

Do you like just a paper weight or a paper wight that works?

Ciao.....Mike


#10

it's certainly nice if you can fix it. I don't think as collector you should collect only working units. In fact many collectors as they don't actually use what they collect so they would collect units that is in good cosmetic condition but not functioning. Sometimes a collector only wants to have the unit to show others how it looks like.


#11

Thanks all... I appreciate your imput. I'm tempted to try to repair, but as was mentioned, I could make matters worse. Hopefully, the corrision has stabized.

#12

Assuming you'd rather have it working than not, because of your delight as a enthusiast, or your conscience as a collector, then one thing to look at would be risk:benefit. Though the current state of your machine could be described as "a pretty paperweight," that status actually has value in a display piece or conversation starter. So if you don't do anything to screw up this attribute of the device by opening it, then the only risk you run is that the machine won't work, and may be even more damaged, when you put it back together. If you are satisfied with the display piece, then that isn't really a risk at all. On the other hand, if that really is an unacceptable risk, then you can choose to send it off to one of the expert calculator repair people. This could be pricey, but may have a better chance of producing a working machine than if you attempt the repair yourself. Finally, you might get a benefit from opening your calculator, even if yo screw it up. You could end up learning something about how the machine ought to work. If this gives you pleasure, then I wouldn't discount it as a benefit.

Best of luck!


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  [O.T.] A collector's question Palmer O. Hanson, Jr. 2 118 12-07-2009, 08:54 PM
Last Post: Palmer O. Hanson, Jr.
  Inefficient Market Theory for the HP collector Mike Ingle 4 210 06-23-2007, 01:02 PM
Last Post: Seth Morabito
  Auction - Definitely Collector Related Howard Owen 1 109 04-27-2007, 03:17 PM
Last Post: Ron
  This collector needs lots of space Klaus 11 296 08-28-2006, 10:01 AM
Last Post: GE
  Win a Free Ruggedized HP50G data collector Tim Wessman 0 74 08-08-2006, 11:55 AM
Last Post: Tim Wessman
  For the Discriminating Collector Howard Owen 3 135 06-24-2005, 12:27 PM
Last Post: Chan Tran
  What about a collector's meeting Matthias 20 672 07-04-2003, 05:07 AM
Last Post: Juergen (CH)
  Re: Collector's Dilemma - Advice Needed frenchem 0 116 12-05-1999, 01:27 AM
Last Post: frenchem
  Collector's Dilemma - Advice Needed Todd Garabedian 5 210 12-01-1999, 04:51 PM
Last Post: Anon
  I am a collector and was wondering...... steve 3 157 10-31-1999, 04:46 PM
Last Post: DaveC

Forum Jump: