Don't buy the 17BII+ !!



#2

Hi all,

I had a discussion with Bob Wang (thanks Bob for the interesting Black Scholes equation).
It is now very clear to me that the 17BII+ is a real piece of junk (no exaggerating).
Let alone the plasticky look and feel, and the noisy keys, the software had no QA whatsoever.
The first version did not have L() and G().
The second version does have them, but obviously there were not tested: they will "work" only if you write a dumb equation to initialize the temporary variables.
On top of that, the solver is not stable. Sometimes it returns a correct answer, sometimes, you get 'overflow' or 'bad guesses' for simple, straitghforward, one root equations.
God knows what else we will discover.
As for me, I have given up on HP, the company that once produced quality devices. I am using the good old 17BII, 19BII, and my beloved 200LX. The programming model of the solver on these three is quite unique, well suited to finance people. I only regret 1) the lack of user-defined functions or subroutines and 2) the lack of break in loops. These could be easily added in a simulator on a PDA... I may work on this someday.
There is no good simulation for these devices, even the so called 'HP-grade' solver of Powerone Finance does not support L() and G()...

HP - rest in peace.

Disgusted Vincent


#3

Vincent,

I am interested in examples of the 17BII+'s solver messing up. I have a presentation for HP calculator solvers in September at the HHC2005 in Chicago.

Thanks,

Namir


#4

Hi Namir,

Just consider the simple equation below:

L(A:2*B)+G(A)=C

First, if you don't initialize A with a dumb equation such as A+B=0, the G() function will return 0. That's a shame on its own, but that has already been covered in this forum.
Now, after initialization, solving for C will work fine, i.e. return 4*<value of B>.
But try to solve for A, regardless of the value of C, and it's another story. Depending on your wonderful 17BII+ mood, you will get 1)Overflow 2)Bad guesses or 3)(rarely) the correct answer.
This seems to depend on the temperature and/or the speed of the wind... while I checked on 17BII AND 19BII AND 200LX, all 3 working -perfectly- fine. But these were other days.

Cheers,
Vincent


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  17BII & 17BII+ Discounted Payback Period Revisited Tom Neudorfl 8 2,870 11-25-2013, 10:28 AM
Last Post: Don Shepherd
  HP-35 blind buy but buggy! Max Stone 7 2,913 11-11-2013, 05:56 PM
Last Post: Dieter
  Another Prime mystery - templates don't work anymore Michael de Estrada 2 1,342 11-02-2013, 11:34 AM
Last Post: Michael de Estrada
  Where to safely buy a PRIME John Stark 14 4,027 10-10-2013, 03:26 PM
Last Post: Terje Vallestad
  Prime Updates (don't get excited yet) Tim Wessman 3 1,529 09-26-2013, 06:18 PM
Last Post: Han
  Warning - Don't update RPN-67 Pro on your iPad Michael de Estrada 9 2,798 05-02-2013, 03:21 PM
Last Post: BShoring
  Good time to buy an HP39GS Charles C(UK) 22 5,608 08-08-2012, 12:55 AM
Last Post: Pete Wilson
  wp34s crystal kits -- don't worry David Griffith 7 2,173 04-16-2012, 04:58 PM
Last Post: Marcus von Cube, Germany
  OT: To All Number Crunchers: Don't miss this VBA numeric library Namir 0 808 04-04-2012, 11:25 AM
Last Post: Namir
  Re: 33s, 35s or 15cLE--which to buy? Eddie W. Shore 20 5,108 03-02-2012, 07:51 PM
Last Post: Massimo Gnerucci (Italy)

Forum Jump: