A prime failure



#19

It seems like the forum turned into a combination of a beta-testing platform an a manual for the Prime. Both don't speak for HP's latest invention. Apparently the new device is full of bugs. And like in the case of the 50g HP is too lousy to supply a decent paper manual with all the inherent ease of use, making the learning curve for the novice a frustrating saga of scrolling along some PDF document in order to find what is being searched for. You may guess it right: I don't like the Prime itself either. My worst objection against it is the clumsy implementation of RPN, which for me as an old school RPN-addict is a reason in itself not to buy one (using the emulator was enough a disappointment). Furthermore, the simplistic programming language (I thought something like BASIC was not to be repeated after it seemed to have faded out) and the inefficient programming environment set the Prime miles apart from the RPL-models of yesteryear and the 50g. The Prime is obviously a calc for kids but not for pros (who better stick to their 50g or their older models). After all: what self-respecting scientist or engineer wants to be seen with a calculator having a triangle-solver dominantly placed among its preimplemented apps. The only thing I appreciate about the prime is its apparent speed, which I would rather see from an updated 50g though.


#20

Quote:
.. too lousy to supply a decent paper manual with all the inherent ease of use, making the learning curve for the novice a frustrating saga of scrolling along some PDF document in order to find what is being searched for.

Print it out 4 pages per side double side and it only cost you about 75 peices of paper and a three ring binder. Perhaps 5 bucks? Or upgrade yourself to the deluxe edition, 2 pages per side double sided for about 5 bucks. Personally I'd opt for the limited edition one page per side... bigger binder... about 10 bucks. But before I put them all in a binder I'm going to run them through my scanner and make electronic copies to use on a PC... :)


I initially had the same misgivings about the Prime... until my wife remarked that I should either 1. send it back or 2. stop bitching and act like an engineer :)


I've kind of grown to love the machine lately... starting to notice my HP 50g has a slight layer of dust starting to accumulate on the case... starting to appreciate just how determined people are to fixing the bugs... hoping to contribute something myself (although my signal to noise ratio here needs improvement)

#21

Quote:
Personally I'd opt for the limited edition one page per side... bigger binder... about 10 bucks.

Lucky you, that you can print it for those prices. I asked at the only local print shop, and they quoted about 30 euro (about 40 dollars) for a one page per side print, with plastic-ring binding... :/ At those prices, I'll want to wait for a more definitive version of the manual!


#22

I was implying that I'd just print it at home :)


#23

Um... I have an HP inkjet printer... printing 600+ pages on that thing would drain more than a whole cartridge, which means I'd pay the same or more than what the shop charges...
What kind of printer do you have to get those prices? :)


#24

Brother MFC-490CW


Aftermarket ink cartridges are $6 shipped to my doorstep... and that's not $6 each... that's for a complete set of 3 colors and 1 black !


When you have 3 young girls that love to print coloring pages, you find a way !


#25

Wow. Very instructive. I'll start looking into ink refills or new (different brand) printers.


#26

I've never tried them... but you can get special cartridges that syphon ink from small tanks.


Here is an example:


http://techreport.com/r.x/2011q3/cobra.jpg

#27

Chris,


Quote:
I'm going to run them through my scanner and make electronic copies to use on a PC... :)

Isn't the PDF already an electronic copy?

Just curious - why scan them?

Bill


#28

My poor attempt at humor... and to illustrate (poorly) that if HP had only shipped a printed manual, pepole would immediately complain that there was no electronic copy... :)


#29

Okay - I get it now.

I had mossed the smiley face at the end of it.

Bill

#30

"stop bitching and act like an engineer"

I did. By not buying a prime.

#31

The reason why the HP Prime seems to be a calculator for kids is because it actually is: HP people clearly stated that the HP Prime was aimed towards high school students, not engineers/professionals. I am pretty sure that their goal was not to upgrade the HP 50g, but rather to compete directly against the TI-Nspire.

That said, they need to work better on their marketing once they fixed the remaining bugs: First of all, the calculator is still not available in any brick-and-mortar store, it is unclear if it will ever be released in Canada (the only way for Canadians to buy it is Hpcalc.org. Even Amazon.ca doesn't have it listed) and finding any info about the HP Prime on HP website is next to impossible. That's now how they'll get the calculator out there.


#32

I know what you mean about the HP Canada website, it is completely useless for finding retailers for calculators, and I was very tersely told the HP Canada online store that the do not sell calculators. I gave up and bought one from Eric Rechlin (hpcalc.org).


#33

Yeah but even on the US website the official site doesn't even list the price and it's very cryptic when you try to find info on where you can buy calcs. Instead, they give you HP resellers that don't sell calcs. Also in Canada, they charge $207.99 for the HP 50g, while in USA, they charge between $90 and $150. And I thought that TI was bad for charging $20-30 higher in Canada than in USA.

If HP decided to charge $208 for the HP 50g in Canada, imagine how much the HP Prime will cost there.


Edited: 6 Dec 2013, 5:06 p.m.


#34

Quote:
Yeah but even on the US website the official site doesn't even list the price...

You are looking at the wrong website, see here.


Edited: 6 Dec 2013, 5:12 p.m.


#35

Thanks for the link. I actually tried to access the US site via http://www.hp.com/calculators/ and when I saw the calc list, the price wasn't listed for the Prime.


#36

HP seems to have a bunch of disconnected websites that are totally inconsistent. I've found their commercial online store to be the most reliable, and it's where I've purchased HP calculators.

Edited: 6 Dec 2013, 8:05 p.m.


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  IR printer failure Andrew Nikitin 7 594 11-05-2013, 11:25 AM
Last Post: Andrew Nikitin
  HP 2225D+ RAM failure/replacement Luca 4 467 09-10-2013, 01:46 PM
Last Post: Luca
  17bii failure db (martinez, ca.) 5 408 01-16-2013, 03:12 PM
Last Post: Jeff O.
  Expected lifetime and failure modes of vintage 15C? Eric Zoob 30 1,628 03-22-2012, 12:02 PM
Last Post: Juan J
  Classic HP LED failure diagnosis aj04062 2 305 09-17-2011, 05:28 PM
Last Post: aj04062
  HP-48G IR Test Failure aj04062 7 505 07-10-2011, 09:22 PM
Last Post: Paul Berger (Canada)
  HP-97 keyboard sudden failure BobVA 0 163 12-04-2010, 08:01 PM
Last Post: BobVA
  HP-65 sensor chip failure aj04062 14 809 08-16-2010, 10:37 PM
Last Post: aj04062
  HP 85 power failure Claudio Perottoni (Brazil) 2 253 07-02-2010, 02:33 PM
Last Post: Claudio Perottoni (Brazil)
  HP42S battery failure Colin McKenzie 0 155 11-26-2009, 04:47 PM
Last Post: Colin McKenzie

Forum Jump: