HP35S solve problem


I'm new in this forum and I have a problem on my 35S: 
when I try to solve for the expression x^2-4 I always find only the
positive root (2) even if I give it two initial estimates like -3
and -1 very close to the negative root (-2).
This happens only trying to solve the expression directly from the
EQN list, if I define the expression in a program and I solve it
giving the same initial estimates, solve result is fine.

This is my operation sequence in RPN mode:
I insert the expression in the EQN list:
[EQN] X^2-4 [ENTER] [C]
I store in the X variable the first estimate (-3)
I store in the X register the second estimate (-1)
from EQN list I recall the expression and I solve it for the variable X:
result is always 2

Could anyone explain me where I wrong ?

Thanks in advance and my best wishes for an happy 2012 to everybody.


Alessandro, there's nothing wrong with your 35s. You just discovered a feature that is often overlooked: the 35s can solve equations symbolically. It does so if the variable appears only once in the equation.

This also happens in your case. Here, the equation

 X^2 - 4
 X^2 - 4 = 0
is automatically transformed to
 X = SQRT(4)
This exact solution is then evaluated by the 35s, using its regular functions. So the square root always returns a positive result.

This also means that - in such a case - the two initial guesses do not matter at all, they are completely ignored.

If you want the usual numerical solution by successive iteration, simply change the equation a bit so that the variable appears twice:

 X*X - 4
 X^2 - 4 = 0*X

All this has been discussed before. For more information and further details, please take a look at this thread.


Edited: 31 Dec 2011, 11:18 a.m.


Thank you very much Dieter.



How fares the 35S with X! = 6 ??

Variable appearing exactly once but there is no inverse gamma function on the device that I'm aware of.

- Pauli


Without using the multiple variable trick in the equation it went for about 40 seconds and I canceled it.

Using the equation

It returned 3.000 (my setting Fix 3) after about 10 seconds.


Well, there are some restrictions so that not all cases with a single appearance of the variable are solved symbolically. For instance, consider periodic functions like sin or cos. An equation like

   SIN(X) = 0,5
will not be solved directly since there is an infinite number of solutions (30, 150, 390, 510, ... degrees). So the 35s will not simply set x = arcsin(0,5) and return 30 degrees.

The case you mentioned

   X! = 6
cannot be solved directly since there is no inverse factorial or inverse Gamma function on the 35s. So the usual iterative approach is applied here. I tried various initial guesses between 0 and 20 - the 35s always came up with the correct result x = 3, usually within 4 - 10 seconds. No tweaking (...+0*X) was required.


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  HP35s Program Four Slings Lift Calculation Jean-Marc Biram (Australia) 2 2,198 12-16-2013, 07:21 PM
Last Post: Jean-Marc Biram (Australia)
  HP35s Calculator Max Rope Tension Program Jean-Marc Biram (Australia) 10 4,358 12-12-2013, 12:03 AM
Last Post: Jean-Marc Biram (Australia)
  XCas / Prime "solve" question Nigel J Dowrick 4 1,998 11-08-2013, 04:01 AM
Last Post: Nigel J Dowrick
  Using the Prime to solve for eigenvalues Michael de Estrada 28 8,479 10-27-2013, 07:21 AM
Last Post: Tarcisi C
  HP Prime Define: Use with solve, etc. Helge Gabert 0 1,001 10-23-2013, 06:24 PM
Last Post: Helge Gabert
  HP 34s solve f'(x)=0 Richard Berler 8 2,582 10-07-2013, 03:03 PM
Last Post: Dieter
  Good puzzle for kids to solve on 35s? snaggs 11 3,381 09-18-2013, 10:40 PM
Last Post: David Hayden
  September SOLVE Newsletter Robert Prosperi 4 1,819 09-07-2013, 01:12 AM
Last Post: Mic
  [HP Prime CAS] Solve Commands (Bugs and Request) CompSystems 10 3,872 08-08-2013, 12:34 PM
Last Post: Gilles Carpentier
  41 SOLVE & INTEG Bank-switched Implementation. Ángel Martin 0 906 06-21-2013, 11:31 AM
Last Post: Ángel Martin

Forum Jump: