Why did this HP-01 fetch so high a price?



#19

Does anyone have any idea why this particular steel HP-01 fetched over US$5,000 on eBay? Sure, it is a very nice one, but that price is way over anything normal. The serial number is missing on the back of the case - I'm not sure if the seller edited it out in the image or if this is a very early HP-01, but it does not look like a prototype.


#20

It's a "private" listing, so may very well be a fake auction designed to create some recent "price history", so some sucker gets duped next time thinking that's the going rate.

Dave.


#21

Hi Dave, that's possible, but judging by this seller's general profile and history, I don't think s/he would do that. I suspect that some sucker has already been pulled in to bidding much more than the going rate. I just wondered if anyone could suggest a reason for someone to bid so high on this particular item. It might make an interesting article for Datafile :-)


#22

I think it was bought by someone who want to collect it with the expectation that the price would go higher. Not someone who really like it.

#23

Quote:
It's a "private" listing, so may very well be a fake auction designed to create some recent "price history"

I'll go out on a limb here and guess you never sold anything on eBay... as the auction will cost the seller over $100 US to create that price history... Unless of course the buyer is defaults and doesn't pay. While that may well be the game, I doubt it based on the sellers history.

I said this about the same time last year and got criticized for it but I'll say it again: 'Tis the season to be stupid.

Okay, so it's not politically correct but it is a general commentary on how eBay prices go nuts this time of the year. People with deep pockets don't know the market values and just keep bidding. There was just a mint 42S that went over $500.00. Not crazy but certainly higher than what the market has been of late.

Personally, I think HP prices on eBay are down a bit, no doubt just following the US economy.


#24

Do you remember the auction?

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rd=1&item=220172797112


It seems the seller still doesn´t have paid the more than 4000 EUR auction ended.

Outrageous prices are not reliable.


#25

How do you know the buyer didn't pay? Based on lack of feedback? Positive feedback may eventually come about, but I expect the negatives come a lot faster. I would think that if he didn't pay, he definitely would have a negative feedback on the auction by now. Unless they worked it out by email.

#26

Quote:
I'll go out on a limb here and guess you never sold anything on eBay...

Plenty actually, close to triple digits I'd estimate.

Quote:
as the auction will cost the seller over $100 US to create that price history... Unless of course the buyer is defaults and doesn't pay.

Correct, it does cost the seller if they try this scam.
But for these people it's usually a full-time cut-throat business for them, and they are not afraid to spend money to make money.
Illegalities aside, wouldn't you spend $100 to make possibly 10-20 times that?
Even if you only got a $200 increase in the price over what you would normally get, you've made an extra $100.
If you are smart you even claim it as a tax deduction on income you never made.

These scams are common, especially in "collectable" markets, and are very effective.

"Private" auctions like this are a big fat warning sign. Avoid.

Dave.

#27

Quote:
I think HP prices on eBay are down a bit,

If it were a US only site, I would tend to agree. But remember ebay is also a currency exchange market. Many currencies are at an all time high compared to the Greenback. While domestic prices may have fallen slightly, the buying power of foreigners has risen significantly.

The prices only look higher to Americans because there is no currency exchange in the middle. A few years ago a 300 EUR bid would appear to us as a $360 purchase, today that exact same 300 EUR bid appears to be $440 -- without raising the bid an extra $80 -- Europeans are spending the same 300!


#28

Quote:
The prices only look higher to Americans because there is no currency exchange in the middle. A few years ago a 300 EUR bid would appear to us as a $360 purchase, today that exact same 300 EUR bid appears to be $440 -- without raising the bid an extra $80 -- Europeans are spending the same 300!

Six years ago those 300 EUR could only buy $265, so the wheel is turning. Your export goes up, including HP paraphernalia.

Greetings,
Massimo

#29

This obviously does't apply in this case, since the bidders were private, but here's the way one scam works:

A scam artists scours eBay for pricey collectible items, usually rare but not one-of-a-kind. He bids to win, but then after the auction closes, deliberately provokes a disagreement with the seller, eventually leading to a mutual agreement to release each other from any obligation to complete the sale.

Now the scam artist rips off the photos and description, and after a while sets up his own auction for the item he doesn't have, and usually makes it a one-day auction at a below-market "Buy it Now" price, with a note in the description about going through some service you've never heard of for payment. He may also give you a direct link for payment or his email, to try and keep below eBay's radar. His hope is that by making it a very short duration auction, he will play on someone's greed to get a cheap deal and will get your money before someone reports him and eBay shuts down the auction and/or warns the buyer.

The reason for his fake attempt to buy the item originally is so the sucker will check out his eBay username and see that he did buy the item previously. Of course, timing is essential, because he has to wait long enough for the item to be shipped to him, plus whatever return period to expire, but before the real owner re-lists it. Or maybe he just waits until after it has been re-listed and sold, hoping the sucker won't check completed listings and find it again.

In this case it is most likely: 1) the winning bid is a schill bid by the seller to maximize the price, and he will now claim non-payment and make a second-chance offer to the second-highest bidder, or 2) just someone with more money than brains.

Edited: 13 Dec 2007, 4:47 p.m.


#30

Quote:
This obviously does't apply in this case

How so?
The seller has made the auction private. The seller can use fake ebay accounts to bid up and buy their own item, totally masked from all who are watching. All the normal punter sees is the price going sky high, and has no recourse to see who's bidding. There is no way to see if the auction is above board.

Dave.

#31

Martin:

You are absolutely correct on all points.

Superb post. Hit the nail on the head.

John

#32

I mentioned this auction to my wife, and she pointed out that there are people for whom $5,000 is about what $50 is to you and I. To such people, it's easier to just buy it at that price than to shop around.

Stefan


#33

I work in the watch business, so have a different view :-)
This one is truly pristine; haven't seen one that good in ages.
The steel are worth more than the gold plated versions, because they wear better and csan be refinished in the long term.
Price is still high, though.
But Christmas is just around the corner, and for a top collector, this is not a big price.
Cheers,
Theo

#34

According with the HP Museum the price of the Stainless Steel HP-01 was $650 (1977-1980 period).

If you would have invested $650 in the S&P 500 back in 1977, 1978, 1979, 1980 you would have at least $9,120, $10,285, $10,320, and $9,175 respectively (maybe a bit less the way the Stock Market is doing today). So, $5,000 now for that watch (almost new) it is a bargain (yet, I would not buy it, not my cup of tea).

Regards, Thor

Note 1: I edited my post to reflect a bit more accurate returns of the S&P 500 I found after I posted. The Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) from Jan 1 1977, 1978, 1979, 1980 to Dec 31 2006 was 8.96%, 9,74%, 10.12%, and 10.03% respectively. And for this year the S&P 500 up 6.85% (as of 12/13/07).

Note 2: The CAGR returns are just capital gains, not dividends so you would have earned more than what my figures show and that is the reason I said "at least" above.


Edited: 14 Dec 2007, 4:52 p.m. after one or more responses were posted


#35

Nor would I :-). But out of interest, since those in the know of the market (I assume) has bashed the price so much... what would a reasonable price be? This is a rare item, right?


#36

Reasonable price? it depends, if I were to buy it with the purpose of investing I would look at the market for guidance on what it is worth (I would look at other sales) but if I were to buy it because "I just have to have it", the value would be proportional to: 1) how bad I want it and 2) the depth of my pocket.

Edited: 14 Dec 2007, 6:07 p.m.


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Reasonable price for a 41C, Quad Mem, Time, Navigation and Card reader module? Eelco Rouw 10 1,913 12-12-2013, 01:52 AM
Last Post: Eelco Rouw
  Very low Price of HP Prime? Harold A Climer 14 1,761 10-10-2013, 01:51 PM
Last Post: Frank Boehm (Germany)
  Last HP emulation, 32 & 01 Olivier De Smet 0 405 09-07-2013, 08:27 AM
Last Post: Olivier De Smet
  Identify HP-01 Prototype parts aj04062 3 719 06-11-2013, 09:49 PM
Last Post: aj04062
  PPC ROM Price Fouad M. Kaadou 7 953 05-17-2013, 01:03 PM
Last Post: Dave Shaffer (Arizona)
  Good deal : HP 12c Platinum for half-price Mic 1 564 01-21-2013, 03:51 AM
Last Post: Vincent Guilbault
  New high def picture of new TI-84 Plus Color SE Mic 17 1,939 11-26-2012, 04:17 PM
Last Post: Luiz C. Vieira (Brazil)
  HP-01 Restoration aj04062 4 705 10-01-2012, 08:52 PM
Last Post: BobVA
  HP-01 Watch John W Kercheval 6 856 05-09-2012, 07:06 AM
Last Post: Maximilian Hohmann
  HIGH END HPs.. Status Symbols?? John W Kercheval 13 1,504 05-09-2012, 12:55 AM
Last Post: Matt Agajanian

Forum Jump: