HP Forums
OT: basic arithmetic functions - Printable Version

+- HP Forums (https://archived.hpcalc.org/museumforum)
+-- Forum: HP Museum Forums (https://archived.hpcalc.org/museumforum/forum-1.html)
+--- Forum: Old HP Forum Archives (https://archived.hpcalc.org/museumforum/forum-2.html)
+--- Thread: OT: basic arithmetic functions (/thread-160743.html)



OT: basic arithmetic functions - Thomas Klemm - 12-10-2009

Recently I purchased a new mobile phone (SAMSUNG SGH-C180) and as always I was curious about the features of the calculator. The manual was short with the description:

Quote:
Perform basic arithmetic functions.

Here's the menu:

*   .
# + - x / % ( )

Just an ordinary four-banger, I was thinking first. But then I realized it conforms to algebraic notation:

2+3*4 = 14
(2+3)*4 = 20

Up to 16 places can be displayed, however at most 6 places after the decimal point:

1000*1000*1000*1000*1000 = Out of range
1000*1000*1000*1000*1000-1 = 999999999999999
(1000*1000*1000*1000*1000*1000-1000)/1000 = 999999999999999
(1000*1000*1000*1000*1000-1)/1000 = 999999999999.999

355/113 = 3.141593
355000000000/113 = 3141592920.353982

1234567890+0.123456 = 1234567890.123456
12345678901+0.123456 = 12345678901.1235
123456789012+0.123456 = 123456789012.123

9876543210+0.123456 = 9876543210.123455
98765432109+0.123456 = 98765432109.1235
987654321098+0.123456 = 987654321098.123

Extracting the square root can be done iteratively
since you can edit the last computation:

(3/1+1)/2 = 2
(3/2+2)/2 = 1.75
(3/1.75+1.75)/2 = 1.732143
(3/1.732143+1.732143)/2 = 1.732051
(3/1.732051+1.732051)/2 = 1.732051

Error messages are nice:

1/0 = Can't divide by zero

But then I stumbled over the following:

23+17% = Syntax Error

Only after a while I found out how to use the percentage operation:

23%17 = 6
355%113 = 16

  • Who'd consider modulo a basic arithmetic function?
  • Have you ever noticed the use of % for this operation in a calculator? (I know it's common in many computer languages.)

Kind regards

Thomas

Edited: 10 Dec 2009, 8:54 p.m.


Re: OT: basic arithmetic functions - hugh steers - 12-10-2009

im thinking the calculator in your phone is working in binary IEEE754 and compiled with the usual runtime mathlib.

you could check by calculating, say 1/17 and then multiplying and subtracting the significant figures. if it's binary, the numbers will go on and on and you will get garbage after 16 digits. if it's decimal, you will hit the zeros.




Re: OT: basic arithmetic functions - Thomas Klemm - 12-15-2009

First I was in doubt since e.g. 1/17*17-1 would just result in 0 as expected. Only after a while I came up with the following expression:

(1-(1000000-999999.999999)*1000000)*10000000000000

Using Python results in:

-76144933.700561523

While the calculator of my phone would yield:

-76144933.700562

I couldn't get any more places since the input field is limited to 50 characters.

So it seems intermediate results are calculated using binary while the result is rounded to 6 places after the decimal point.

Of course HP-calculators using BCD don't encounter problems with this expression.