HP Forums
HP17b Solver Function - Printable Version

+- HP Forums (https://archived.hpcalc.org/museumforum)
+-- Forum: HP Museum Forums (https://archived.hpcalc.org/museumforum/forum-1.html)
+--- Forum: Old HP Forum Archives (https://archived.hpcalc.org/museumforum/forum-2.html)
+--- Thread: HP17b Solver Function (/thread-159339.html)



HP17b Solver Function - Roland Storz - 11-12-2009

Hi all,

does anybody know whether the functionality of the HP17b Equation Solver is available for the iphone / ipod touch?

Both the i41cx+ and the 42s emulation are unquestionably excellent, however, me personelly I do miss the easy to use solver function of the 17b.
In my eyes specifically the solver function of the 42s is not that efficient compared to the 17b.

Any advice?

Cheers, Roland


Re: HP17b Solver Function - Dave Britten - 11-12-2009

I would like having this myself, but I've not seen any 17bii simulators, unfortunately.

There were, however, a number of devices produced by HP that feature the same HP Solve:

17b - Probably the cheapest option, but missing L() and G(). (...and RPN!)

17bii - Same as the 17b, with L() and G() added.

17bii+ - Same as the 17bii, but there were some changes that cause L() and G() to behave differently. I'd stay away from this one.

18c - No L(), G(), or looping.

19b/19bii - Includes trig functions, I believe.

22s - Has trig and scientific functions, but no finance, and missing L(), G(), and looping.

27s - Same as 17bii, but no cash flow lists, and it apparently only uses iteration, not algebraic simplification.

95LX - About the same as the 19bii, plus you can back-solve in Lotus 1-2-3. Can be found cheaply from time to time.

100LX - About the same as the 95LX, but some ROM versions have a bug with reading cash-flow lists.

200LX - About the same as the 95LX, but no bugs that I'm aware of. Most feature complete, but can be pricey.

OmniGo - Pretty sure it had the same solver, but was missing some features.

There was also a Windows (3.1) version for some older models of OmniBook, I believe.

You might also consider downloading one of the 48GX emulators for iPhone/iPod. The 48 has an algebraic solver that's somewhat similar to HP Solve, but without L(), G(), and looping.


Re: HP17b Solver Function - Don Shepherd - 11-12-2009

Quote:
17b - Probably the cheapest option, but missing L() and G(). (...and RPN!)

Dave, the 17b does have L() and G(). At least mine does. The manual was missing a description of those functions, but they were in the ROM.

Quote:
17bii+ - Same as the 17bii, but there were some changes that cause L() and G() to behave differently. I'd stay away from this one.

The + has a whole different solver, and it does not work like the solver in the original 17b and bii. See this articlefor a discussion of the differences in these solvers.




Re: HP17b Solver Function - Martin Pinckney - 11-12-2009

Also, I would point out that the 22s solver is quite different from the others in many ways, not the least of which is having no alpha capability, other than single letter variables.


Re: HP17b Solver Function - Dave Britten - 11-12-2009

Yeah, looks like it's more akin to the 32sii, 33s, and 35s solvers, i.e. nothing terribly remarkable.


Re: HP17b Solver Function - Bruce Bergman - 11-12-2009

The 19bii was one of the nicest of this family. As a close second, I would recommend the most recent 17bii+.

thanks,
bruce