HP Forums

Full Version: Free42 for sale at eBay?
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.

Interesting. It's not against the GPL to charge for distributing software. The source needs to come with, or be otherwise accessible from the distributed package.

There's not much "value-add" that I can see in that offer, however. And with the software's name prominently displayed, I doubt he gets any bids.

We could suggest the seller to add a link to Free42 so that potential buyers have a little more information about 'his' product... :-)

It is against eBay rules, if there is any shareware aspect to this calculator. I mean if he has any features that require a fee to access, it's an illegal auction.

That's interesting, I didn't know that.

GPL software isn't shareware, its free (like in freedom) software. The license states that you can charge for distribution of GPLd software if you like. That's what all the major Linux vendors do, for example. Is that different from selling your software for a fee, where "selling" means "selling the media and a right to use license?" I don't know.

Come to think, you can buy plain proprietary software on eBay. It even has a rather extensive category. So the difference must be the delayed payment in shareware. You "try before you buy" then eBay doesn't get a cut when you eventually pay. I'll bet that's it. So then the GPL software wouldn't differ from proprietary in that respect, since all the money is transferred up front where eBay can tax it.

I wrote Thomas Okken about this auction and provided him with the seller's email address.


... I doubt he gets any bids.

I doubted it too but he's got two bids so far... Five hours to end and the price has reached 12 Euro.

I don't think this auction is against eBay's rules -- Free42 is not shareware; there are no optional features that require extra payment to unlock etc. As long as the seller is selling a version that has my copyright, my web site URL, and my email address, I don't see anything wrong with this... Woe to the suckers who don't Google "Free42" before making a bid.

Hmmm, maybe I should contact the winning bidder and ask them if the software they receive has been tampered with.